Showing posts with label notes. Show all posts
Showing posts with label notes. Show all posts

Sunday, March 13, 2011

Cold Ring Catalysts: Co-Optive Strategies of Urban Logistics

Thesis Title:


Cold Ring Catalysts: Co-Opting Strategies of Urban Logistics

Cold storage is an emerging network of public infrastructures for design opportunities along the busiest logistical corridor of North America: the NAFTA superhighway.

Much of the cold chain's pull on this highway originates from the Great Lakes Mega Region, but this thesis concerns itself with the southern tail: the emerging Texas Triangle.

The critical nexus of this global-regional crossroads is the metropolis of Laredo-Nuevo Laredo: the prototype for the logistical city.

This thesis claims that logistical entities such as cold storage have had the greatest impact on the spatial development of cities. This thesis also claims that if architects and urbanists still wish to be active agents in this process, much can be learned by studying and co-opting the logic of cold storage with a set of new design protocols.

The Scenario: Increasing Cold Trade Volumes

Global Cold Storage trade volume is projected to grow by 4% per year and its capacity will likely increase along the NAFTA Superhghway. The impact will increase carbon foot print, increased consumption of water and electricity in freezing/cooling activities, accumulation of pollution (i.e. refrigerant gasses and transport emissions) at site and arriving to the site.

With the Obama administrations restoration of the Mexican trucking program and the increasing consumer lifestyle demand for time-sensitve perishiable goods, the urban fate of Los Dos Laredos are at stake. How can architects and urbanists intervene in this inevitable process?

Catalyzing Cold Storage with New Urban Protocols

The Los Does Loredos must co-opt the inevitable and indifferent logic of cold storage with a set of urban design protocols that turns them into catalysts for potential new urban spaces, forms and programs. The first mover advantage does mean something here in this unrealized game of spatial city development. The end goal of these protocols is a phased in concentric nodal urbanism that generates a healthy and beneficial impact on the local, border, regional, and global scales of logistics.

Saturday, January 22, 2011

Underground Storage of Thesis Projects

Hacking big ice boxes is tougher than expected.  Two maneuvers are of worth consideration for this thesis.  

First, despite the explicit rules imposed by a storage facility for tight efficiencies of space, every site and architecture must have unexpected consequences or byproducts as a result of these rules.  After all, no generated spreadsheet for the planning of a new storage facility can possibly account for every cost or benefit. At best, these logistical regimes default to coping mechanisms of categorically placing these very unknown variables in insurance terms of "contingencies" or "acts of god".  The small details that are left out of this planning equation is where architect as hacker needs to be looking at closely.

As of now, byproducts that are worth considering at the architectural level:
  • Emissions from the mechanical systems that support the temperature controlled rooms
  • Accumulations that are brought to the site via trucking and rail.
  • Impervious surfaces and drainage of phosphorus.
Second, the code for formatting the spatial development of storage facilities resides in the faulty language of bureaucratic planning documents.  Again, its rule making explicitness is prescribed in quantitative measures of x-feet above, below, or back from the street.  This logic is buried in the bureaucratic pages of planning documents but inevitably physically manifests in the forms of setbacks and property lines  staked into the ground.  The legal loopholes of the language needs to be hacked, then a demonstration of the set of hacking tactics needs to be demonstrated (Alex Lehnerer's Grand Urban Rules or Sub Plan).

Underground Storage

Meanwhile, the default mode of hacking projects resort to program.  The legacy of Dutch architects have taught us that its the program stupid!  Tongue-in-cheek as these projects maybe, these projects have been successful in repurposing, infilling, and retrofitting of depleted or used up post-industrial sites seems to be in vogue.  Pertaining to the thesis at hand are underground storage facilities cropping up in old limestone mines.  The melting waters of ice age past and the coursing water of the Missouri set the stage for productive industrial sites of extraction.  The activity continues, but not of the same intensity nor of the same locale.  Its productive work resides in the network of gravel pits that pave way for the expanding suburban streets.  The old sites of extraction becomes a relic of Fordist economies.  In this case, the functional repurposing of a site of extraction into one of conveyance and accumulation of goods 

Docking Area


If the thesis project was to employ the same kind of program centric tactic, it would look like the following equation:  

Intermodal Distribution Center in Cold Commodities + ___(x-plus)                         
                                                                                              education                     
                                                                                          __tourism                         
                                                                                              shopping/dinning         
                                                                                          _  recreation                     
                                                                                          __hotel   _____________

All of the above mentioned x-plus that the supposed architect as agent brings to the table are tinged with a consumer culture of fetishizing the box.  NeoMarxist critiques are powerful and hard to escape, something I don't think you can totally escape from, but if this thesis really is going to consider combining the topic of health, it needs to be worry about health becoming a derivative for a fast-serving IKEA of Health and Personal Health products and services on full spectacle.  

Offices

This thesis project acknowledge program as a method, but aspires to hack without having to solely resort to such means. 

Working Project Titles:

Cold Empires
The Cold Chain Complex
Cold Chain Complex
ProtoPharmopia
Pharmopia
Pharmoplis
Pharmacopic Follies
Pharmacopic Post

Mall Medica
Medi-log
Meditopia
Mecha-Medilistics
Mega Medical Stop
Mega Medical Exchange
Medi-Mart
Mega-Mini Mart
Medical Mechanica
MechaPharm
MechaPharm Logistics
Mecha-Medi-Mart

The Medi-market exchange
Medica's
Medilistic's

Guns-Meds-Foods
The Cold Zone
Health Zone
The Ice Stop
The Health Stop
The Health Exchange



Saturday, January 15, 2011

Notes from Networked Cities

Universal  Situated
anytime-anyplace | responsive place
     mostly portable | mostly embedded
          Ad hoc aggregation | Accumulated aggregation
context is location | context is activity
           fast and far | slower and closer
uniform | adapted

-Malcolm McCullough


Sunday, December 5, 2010

Re-Hacking the Expanded Field

Hacking the Expanded Field

In Rosalind Krauss’s 1979 essay Sculpture in the Expanded Field, she observed how sculptural works of the 1960s and 1970s in America were experiencing a paradigmatic shift in its logic and rule making abilities of the discipline.  Set in backdrop of an aesthetic polemic that posited post-modernism's opposition to all things modern, Krauss' theoretical repositioning of sculpture was in parallel to the times.  Sculpture's rules and logics were redefined by setting it in opposition and exclusion to the categories of other major creative fields such as landscape and architecture (see figure 1).  Sculpture in the traditional modern aesthetic sense, had actually been left behind as sculptors began to hack at different mediums at the edge of these expanded fields.  Visually represented in a Kline group structure, Krauss also identified 3 additional emerging practices with their own set of logic: site construction, marked sites, and axiomatic structures.  

In 2009, the architectural blog InfraNet Lab, posted a similar but revised diagram of architecture’s relative position in its newly expanded field (see figure 2a).  Whether the zeitgeist of a paradigmatic shift runs in a similar streaming thought of Krauss' time is questionable but the blog stakes its claim:

“Architecture is in need of a range of situational qualifiers to establish its position amongst the rapidly expanding terrain of landscape architecture and within the fractured and troubled territory of urbanism.”  

Unlike Krauss’ maintenance of sculpture at the edge of her field, InfraNet cleverly removes the term architecture and replaces it with urbanism.  The proposed Neo-Kraussian diagram no longer displays 'architecture'  but more powerful exposes its hacked logic.  InfraNet has managed to slip architecture into this self-propagating disciplinary framework model which results in even wider disciplinary implications.  For example, the original logic of the Kline Group structure (i.e., its reliance on exclusive qualifiers) generates disciplinary topics and operable spaces such as infrastructure, productive surface, civic conduit, and spatial container which are of relevancy to architecture. Furthermore, these terms also imply wider disciplinary fields of flows, velocities, ecologies, economics, and energies.  

InfraNet's hacking play is in alignment with the earlier quoted observation and perhaps its hopeful goal of re-situating the architectural field.  A better position anticipates that architecture can address critical "disciplinary loopholes" that are being displaced in traditional fields of economics, geography, ecology, and landscape.  Furthermore, they pose the open ended question of ‘now what’ or ‘how’ to the architects that must propose a design!

Re-Hacking an Expanded Field

Hacker as architect not only assumes the playing field of logistical cities but the architectural discourses at hand.  In the ethos of disciplinary hacking, the hacker as architect further problematizes the lingering set of questions asked by InfraNet by asking ‘what else?’  

First, the current InfraNet iteration of the Kline Group still maintains the logic of exclusion and opposition to the organization.   This is a quick and simple way of organizing the discipline by distinction but perhaps limiting in its ability to contextualize and encourage interdisciplinary streams for new knowledge.  The hacker proposes the removal of these ‘not-’s of distinction.

Second, the hacker agrees with InfraNet that marking the expanded field in architecture with their four newly generated terms (see figure 3a) can be helpful for understanding new purposes or opportunities for architecture within the local and regional networks.  However, further reconfigurations of these opportunities are in order due to the removal of the ‘not-’s that supported each respective term, except for infrastructure. 

Third, the hacker also acknowledges the newly defined disciplinary territories of ecologies, economics, energies, velocities that emanate from flows. InfraNet’s insertion of ‘flows’ into the diagram’s logic is perhaps the most ingenious iteration.  However, the hacker is aware that in our finite existence of a continuing conversation, we don’t always recognize this central configuration.  Many times we are busy controlling and regulating the flow of discourses- and materials- through our own expanded territories of production and accumulation (see figure 3c).

Fourth, the Kline diagram may have evolved to an organization of expanding networks but lacks critical elements of linearity and time (see figure 4).  Critics such as Easterling comment on how architecture has “few common terms to describe spatial organization with active parts, temporal components, or differential change.”  Perhaps the flow may be non-linear in order of progression as DeLanda likes to suggest.  However, at a certain point there must be a continuity which leads to produced and accumulated knowledge.  After all, flows emanating from a center inevitably turn into many streaming narratives as it must engage the barriers and obstacles of entry into each respective disciplinary territories.  Otherwise the streaming narratives would regress to systems of purely abstracted points and lines of intersection.  What happens to the flow as it engages each territory is the most crucial for hacker’s operations to commence in what is called the  “exchange”.

Thus, this thesis re-hacks contemporary working models of an expanded field of architecture.  The never ending generative net of narrative streams that emanated with a central area of flows has evolved into inverted characteristics with the direction of flows traveling in a linear movement (see figure 5) .  The ever expanding disciplinary territories (i.e., production and accumulation) encroach and networking with one another as its re-displace terms of infrastructure, urbanism, landscape and civic conduit occupy its overlapping areas.  Meanwhile, the linear flow reorganizes the four terms into a sequence that enables it to shuttle back and forth between the peripheral territories of production and accumulation and remains hyper active in the center of exchange.

Wednesday, December 1, 2010

2 scentence abstract

Two possible thesis statements:

A:  Hack the logic of emerging logistical cities in its given expanded playing fields and finite plays; infinite campaigns to flow. Then we too might exercise our agency to the fullest.

or

B:  Hack the finite logic of emerging logistical cities in its given expanded playing fields and finite plays; infinite campaigns to flow. Then we too might exercise our role as synthesizer and bearer of variance to the fullest in the many streaming narratives.


Other lexicons to consider:

Game/System
Insert
Slip
Operate
Tactic
Strategy
Variance/Xplus
Accommodate
Expand
New
Finite
Infinite

Concerning the Intent of the thesis or perhaps role of the architect as hacker:

Respond with tactics that are seeking to accommodate these influences in a more expansive way

or

with tactics that seek to use the act of architecture as an opportunity to alter the processes influencing that territory.

Hacker must be mindful of two kinds of time-based play of rule making in this game: the finite and infinite.  Logistics is quite skilled at the finite, and increasingly better at the infinite due to its amassing of digital tools of projection.  Architects are skilled at the infinite, but needs work on the finite. Why? Because these small endgame plays are when the stakes are the highest if architects are to ever exercise their agency in the infinite.

Relative Thesis Position in the Paradigm Map/Expanded Field:

not too satisfied with this layout of expanded field diagram, as it still deal with conditional statements as a way to organize and topical in nature (legacy of dualism in Western dialogues pervade).  maybe a future exercise that re-arranges the diagram of discipline in a field of expanding and contracting linear streams? for now, relative interest in the thesis in the right half.

Thesis Allies of Precedents and Design Practices:

Easterling for analysis,
Varnelis for projections,
Lateral Office for tactics and strategies

Quote worthy:

The field of Game Theory, which studies the dynamics of negotiation, lays out similar bargaining strategies players (in the case of the city, these include property owners, neighbors, merchants, city agencies, etc.) use as they cross their own political and economic objectives with a finite set of available options. [...] Even if never precisely predictable, the endgame is nearly always the same: to settle upon an equilibrium enforced by each player’s self-interest. More than any other single logic, it is the nature of how this inevitable quid pro quo, or tradeoff is settled that offers the greatest potential as a productive instigator of change-by-design: where design is nothing less that a strategy of both staging and creatively working out the causal relationships that comprise the city-as-ecosystem, and in so doing not only makes evident but actually constitutes the tie that binds the system.
-Roger Sherman

Saturday, October 30, 2010

storage yesterday and today

yesterday's storage:  architecture is containment / production
today's storage:  architecture is process/conveyance

Saturday, October 23, 2010

Cargo Cult

wiki link on the influence of cargo on culture: cargo culture

Contacts between members of different cultures can often produce misunderstandings. These misunderstandings are not limited to an isolated society's first contact with the other cultures—a result, for example, of exploration, colonization, missionary efforts or warfare. Often people will have doubts about the fully human nature of those being encountered: outsiders will also have difficulties understanding those from the isolated society. Attempts may be made by both sides to fit the contact into the existing beliefs of the culture, with members of the other culture being assimilated to various non-human roles: spirits, demons, animals.[citation needed] With time, each culture learns that the others are mortal and that their respective material cultures differ in important ways. Disagreements often arise over how parts of this material culture (whether manufactured goods (the "cargo") or handicrafts) are shared. In cargo cults, natives develop rituals that express their disagreements with outsiders who refuse to share cargo on acceptable terms.